Homepage Content Auto, Home, Business Insurance - Muncie, New Castle, Shelbyville, As one of the region’s leading independent insurance agencies, Pfenninger, Claxton, & Estelle Insurance Group, is happy to serve the diverse insurance needs of Indiana individuals, families and businesses—along with providing superior risk management services.With four convenient locations in Muncie, New Castle, Shelbyville and Rushville in Indiana, ours is a long-standing, full-service insurance agency dedicated to providing you with the highest quality strategies. As a well-established local agency, we have access to top-rated carriers nationwide, allowing us to offer you the best rates throughout the state.Since 1902, our team has worked hard to build a strong, knowledgeable community of agents and insurance carriers. Additionally, we strive to foster a positive agency reputation which is dependent upon mutual understanding between agent and client. We welcome you to join our family and learn about our broad book of options for auto, home, business, life and group health insurance.At Pfenninger, Claxton, & Estelle Insurance Group, we know everyone and every policy is truly unique. Contact us to speak with an agent right now—get a free Muncie insurance quote and discover your options for customizable insurance coverage today!